Imperfect Progress: Why ‘Flawed’ Candidates May Be Your Best Hires

When it comes to hiring, we often find ourselves chasing the myth of perfection. But what if the very traits we overlook in candidates are the ones that could transform our teams?

For decades, hiring has been dominated by the search for the ‘perfect’ candidate: spotless resumes, linear career paths, and impeccable references. However, this approach may be holding companies back in an era that values adaptability and innovation. Imperfections often signal resilience, creativity, and untapped potential—qualities that organizations need now more than ever.

‍

Unmasking the Myth of the Perfect Candidate

In today’s dynamic job market, chasing the "perfect" candidate often does more harm than good. Traditional hiring models prioritize flawless resumes and linear career trajectories, overlooking candidates who bring adaptability, creativity, and diverse perspectives.

Many professionals take unconventional paths like career breaks or industry pivots that foster skills like problem-solving and resilience, which are invaluable in today’s workplaces. Research shows that 60% of hiring managers consider adaptability one of the top skills for modern roles. By focusing solely on perfection, companies risk missing opportunities for innovation and growth.

Unicorn job postings compound this issue by demanding candidates with the skill set of an entire team or requiring years of experience in nascent technologies. These unrealistic expectations deter qualified candidates, especially specialists and T-shaped professionals while attracting generalists who may lack the depth needed for the role. The result? Fewer applicants and missed connections with exceptional talent.

To attract the best candidates, companies should simplify job postings by prioritizing essential skills and separating nice-to-haves. By emphasizing potential over perfection, hiring managers can uncover candidates with transferable skills and fresh perspectives. This shift enables organizations to foster a more inclusive, innovative, and effective hiring process.

The Hidden Value of Imperfections

Looking beyond the surface of a candidate’s imperfections often reveals their strengths:

• Career Gaps: Time away from work can indicate personal growth, skill acquisition, or experiences that make candidates more empathetic and resilient.
• Frequent Job Changes: Rather than signalling instability, this reflects a candidate’s adaptability and eagerness to learn in diverse environments.
• Unconventional Backgrounds: Professionals transitioning from different industries bring unique perspectives and fresh ideas to solve traditional problems.

These so-called imperfections aren’t always weaknesses; they’re opportunities to build diverse, dynamic teams capable of navigating today’s challenges.

How to Identify Potential in “Imperfect” Candidates

To uncover the potential hidden in unconventional candidates, consider these strategies:

• Candidates with Employment Gaps:some text
  • Negative Perception: Viewed as "out of touch" or uncommitted.
  • Positive Reality: Gaps may represent periods of self-reflection, skill-building, or personal growth.
  • Example: A candidate who organized a community event during their gap showcases project management, leadership, and resourcefulness.
• Self-Employed Candidates:some text
  • Negative Perception: Assumed to struggle with teamwork or unable to fit into corporate structures.
  • Positive Reality: Self-employment builds entrepreneurial thinking, risk taking, and adaptability.
  • Example: A freelancer who aligned conflicting stakeholder needs through customer feedback demonstrates initiative and solution-oriented thinking.
• Candidates with Short Stays or Contract Roles:some text
  • Negative Perception: Seen as "job-hoppers."
  • Positive Reality: Excelling in short-term roles highlights adaptability and dealing with ambiguity.
  • Example: A professional who delivered a process improvement plan in a 6-month contract role demonstrates prioritization and performance under pressure.
• Candidates with Long-Term Roles:some text
  • Negative Perception: Viewed as resistant to change.
  • Positive Reality: Long tenures often build deep expertise and institutional knowledge.
  • Example: Managing a significant internal change demonstrates leadership and stakeholder alignment over time.

‍

From Rejection to Revolution: WhatsApp’s Founding Story

The story of WhatsApp’s founders, Jan Koum and Brian Acton, is an example of how a ‘flawed’ candidate was overlooked.

Koum, who emigrated from Ukraine, a former security engineer at Yahoo! and Acton, a Stanford graduate and Yahoo! Colleague, faced a rejection from Facebook in 2007. Then, they channelled their experiences into developing WhatsApp. By focusing on user-friendly functionality and speed, they launched a product that revolutionized messaging. In 2014, Facebook—ironically, the company that rejected them—acquired WhatsApp for $19 billion. Their journey is a reminder that resilience, adaptability, and non-linear career paths can drive extraordinary outcomes.

Perfect Isn’t Always Better

The pursuit of perfection in hiring is an outdated strategy. Candidates who’ve navigated challenges, learned from their experiences, and emerged stronger are often the ones who succeed in today’s workplaces.

The next time you review a resume, ask yourself: Are you looking for a flawless candidate or one with the potential to drive meaningful change?

Rethink Your Hiring Strategy with Optima Search

At Optima Search, we specialize in uncovering talent others overlook. Our tailored approach ensures your team benefits from the creativity and resilience of unconventional candidates.

Subscribe to our LinkedIn newsletter at Optima Search | Europe & America for more hiring insights and strategies.

Stay curious and let’s build extraordinary teams together! 

‍